Documenting Your Case: What Evidence Helps in Challenging a Denial?

Question

Accepted Answer

Whether you are appealing within the HOA or preparing for potential legal action, proper documentation can be your best friend. A well-documented case can make all the difference in demonstrating that the HOA acted unfairly or outside its authority. Here are key pieces of evidence and documentation to gather and organize:

The Governing Documents: Obtain and review the HOA’s Declaration, CC&Rs - Covenants, Conditions & Restrictions, bylaws, and any published architectural guidelines or standards. These are the rules of the game. Carefully review the sections relevant to your project and the denial. For instance, highlight any clause that the HOA cited in denying your request, as well as any clause that supports your position (like one that says approvals won’t be unreasonably withheld, if such language exists). Having the exact wording at hand is important when making your argument. If you don’t have the latest copy of these documents, request them from your HOA – under NC law, members have a right to access the governing documents and most HOA records.

Your Application and Plans: Keep a copy of the complete architectural request you submitted, including all forms, drawings, photos, and descriptions you provided. This is important to show that you followed the proper procedure and gave the HOA the information needed. If the HOA claims you left something out, you can prove what you did submit. It also serves as a baseline if you make any revisions in an appeal; you can point out how the new plans differ from the original.

HOA Correspondence and Notices: Maintain a file of all communications with the HOA regarding your request. This includes the official denial letter (or email), any warning or violation letters if things escalated, and any emails or letters between you and HOA representatives about the project. If you had phone calls or in-person conversations with board or committee members, make a written note of what was discussed and the date, or follow up with an email to confirm the conversation (“Thank you for meeting with me today. As we discussed, the committee’s main concern is X…”). This creates a paper trail. If the HOA gave you certain reasons verbally that weren’t in the letter, having them documented in an email recap can be very helpful later to avoid any “he said, she said” issues.

Evidence of Similar Approvals (or Inconsistencies): One powerful piece of evidence in an unfair denial case involves showing how similar situations were treated. Take photographs of other homes in your community that have the same or similar modification that you proposed (for example, a photo of a neighbor’s shed or addition that looks like what you want). Note the addresses and dates if possible. If you can get confirmation that those neighbors obtained approval (maybe from talking to them or from HOA minutes), even better – but the existence of those structures might support an argument of inconsistent enforcement. Also gather any newsletter or report where the HOA may have noted approvals of projects. If no one else has what you’re proposing, that’s fine, but if they do, it could be critical evidence for selective enforcement or that your idea isn’t outlandish for the community.

Photos and Expert Opinions: If aesthetics are in question, visuals can be compelling. For example, provide documentation of what your house will look like after the change – show that it will blend in nicely. A photo-simulated image is a digitally created visual representation that combines photographs of an existing location or landscape with proposed structures or changes. It realistically illustrates how a planned project would appear in the actual setting, helping viewers visualize future modifications before construction begins.
If the dispute involves something technical (like structural safety or drainage from your project), consider getting a statement from a professional (architect, engineer, contractor) that the plan is sound and won’t cause issues. An expert letter or report could counter any vague claims the HOA made about “concerns” related to the project. Also, if part of your case is that the condition of your property necessitated the change (say, a tree was dying and you needed to build a retaining wall), photos of the situation can provide context. Essentially, use evidence to tell a story: what you want to do, why it’s reasonable, and how it won’t harm the community.

Records of HOA Procedure and Timelines: Document the timeline of your request. Note when you submitted the application, when the HOA responded, and any deadlines involved. If the HOA missed a deadline (for example, some covenants state the HOA must respond within 30 or 60 days or the request is automatically approved), this fact could become a key part of your case. Keep copies of meeting agendas or minutes where your request was discussed (you may request these from the HOA – minutes are part of official records). If you appealed, keep all related documents, including your appeal letter and any notes from the appeal meeting. Having a clear chronology can show, for instance, that you gave the HOA ample opportunity to review and they may have dropped the ball.

Communications from Neighbors or Other Support: If any neighbors are supportive of your project (or similarly frustrated with the HOA’s decision), their input could be beneficial. A friendly neighbor might write a brief note stating they have no objection to your proposed improvement – countering any claim that “neighbors would be negatively affected.” Be cautious with this, as you don’t want to stir up a neighborhood feud or involve others unnecessarily, but in some cases, a statement from a long-time community resident or former board member that the denial seems unfair can carry weight with current board members or even in court. It may also serve as additional evidence that reasonable people in the community disagree with the HOA’s stance.

Financial or Personal Impact Documentation: If the denial is causing you financial harm (perhaps you put down a deposit with a contractor or bought materials), keep receipts, contracts, or cancellation fees related to the project. If the improvement is needed for a personal reason (for example, a ramp for accessibility for a disabled resident), having medical or related documents to demonstrate the need can be important. While you might not share these personal documents in an initial HOA appeal, they could become relevant if you have to show hardship or reasons why the HOA should have granted an exception. Courts in some cases do weigh the hardship on the owner versus the benefit to the HOA of enforcing a particular rule.

When Is Legal Action Appropriate Against an HOA Over Architectural Requests?

Deciding When to Take Legal Action Against Your Wilmington HOA for Architectural Denials

HOA Disputes in Wilmington: Call Attorney Bradley Coxe

Address

What People Say?